Reseller guides

Cost of Goods Sold for eBay Resellers: How to Track It for Taxes

Thrift receipts, a calculator and a notebook of figures on a kitchen table with two thrifted finds

When tax time comes, the marketplaces report what you sold. They don’t report what you paid for it. That second number, your cost of goods sold, is what keeps you from paying tax on money you never made. Here’s how it works for resellers, and how to keep the records without a spreadsheet headache.

Good to know: this guide explains the basics for U.S. resellers in plain words. It isn’t tax advice, and rules depend on your situation, so check the details with a tax preparer.

What cost of goods sold means for a reseller

Cost of goods sold (often shortened to COGS) is what you paid for the items you sold this year. If you bought a lamp for $8 and sold it for $45, the $8 is cost of goods sold. Your profit on that lamp, before fees and shipping, is $37.

The key word is sold. What you spent buying inventory isn’t automatically this year’s cost. Items still sitting on your shelves at the end of the year generally count when they sell, not when you bought them.

Why it matters so much

The simple year-end formula

For most small resellers, cost of goods sold for the year comes from three numbers:

Inventory at the start of the year (what unsold stock cost you on January 1)
+ Purchases (everything you bought for resale during the year)
− Inventory at the end of the year (what unsold stock cost you on December 31)
= Cost of goods sold

Example: you started the year with $1,500 of unsold stock, bought $6,000 more, and ended the year with $2,000 still unsold. Your cost of goods sold is $1,500 + $6,000 − $2,000 = $5,500.

If you’re a sole proprietor or single-member LLC, this usually ends up in the cost of goods sold section of Schedule C. Your tax preparer or tax software will ask for these numbers.

What counts as cost, and what doesn’t

Generally part of an item’s cost:

Usually not part of cost of goods (they’re separate business expenses):

Both lower your taxable profit; they’re just reported in different places. Keep them apart in your records so the totals are clean.

A hand photographing a thrift store receipt in a car next to a bag of finds
Snap the receipt before you leave the parking lot.

The records to keep

The good news: you don’t need much, as long as you capture it when you buy.

Tip: the hardest records to rebuild are the ones from the store. Twenty seconds at checkout (snap the receipt, note the cost) saves hours of guessing in March.

A hand sorting through an estate sale box of cameras, jewelry and postcards
One price for the whole box: split it across the items so every sale has a cost.

Lots and bulk buys

You paid $60 for a box of 20 items. What did each one cost? You need a reasonable way to split the total, and then to stick with it:

Either way, keep the lot’s total and date, and make sure the split adds back up to what you paid. Items from the lot you throw away or donate still carry their share.

Someone with a clipboard counting storage bins of inventory in December
December 31: what your unsold stock cost you is next year’s starting inventory.

Unsold inventory at year end

On December 31, write down what your unsold stock cost you. That’s your ending inventory this year and your starting inventory next year. Count everything you still intend to sell: listed items, the ones waiting to be listed, and the bins in the garage.

If you kept cost records as you bought, this is a total, not a weekend of counting. If you didn’t, a careful one-time count with your best estimates is far better than nothing, and it sets you up for next year. Some small businesses can use simpler methods for inventory; ask your preparer whether one fits you.

Donated and written-off items

Things break, don’t sell or turn out to be missing pieces. When you donate or throw away inventory, keep a note of what it was, the date and what it cost you. Those costs don’t disappear: how they’re handled depends on your situation, so give the list to your preparer rather than leaving them out. Our real death pile guide walks through an example.

Common mistakes

A year-end checklist

  1. Make sure every sold item this year has a cost recorded.
  2. Total your purchases for the year (including lots and any inbound shipping).
  3. Total the cost of your unsold inventory on December 31.
  4. List donated and written-off items with their costs.
  5. Download your marketplace sales and fee reports.
  6. Hand it all to your preparer (or your tax software) in one folder.

Quick answers

Do I need to track costs if I only sell a little?

If you sell things for more than you paid, it’s worth it. Even a few hundred dollars of sales can mean real tax without your costs to subtract. Selling your own used belongings for less than you paid is a different situation; ask your preparer.

Can I estimate costs I didn’t write down?

Reasonable, honest estimates are better than leaving costs at zero, but records made at the time are much stronger. Start logging purchases now so next year is easy.

Are eBay fees part of cost of goods sold?

Usually not. Final value fees, payment fees and promoted listing fees are generally selling expenses, recorded separately from cost of goods sold. They still lower your taxable profit, so keep them in your records; ask your preparer how to report them.

Is shipping to the buyer part of cost of goods?

Usually not. Postage and supplies to send sold items are typically separate expenses. They still reduce your profit.

How ReNventory helps

  • Cost captured in the store. Log a find with a photo or barcode, type what you paid (or snap the price tag), and it gets a SKU and today’s date, even with no signal.
  • Lots split for you. Enter a box or lot’s total once; ReNventory spreads it across the items, and the split always adds back up to what you paid.
  • “Cost not set” warnings. Items without a cost (like eBay imports) are flagged, so nothing sells at a $0 cost by accident. Add costs in bulk on the website.
  • A yearly report. The Reports tab shows sales, cost of goods sold, profit, write-offs, inventory bought and unsold inventory at year end, with a Download for my accountant spreadsheet listing every sale and write-off.
  • Write-offs on the record. Move an item to the Death Pile as donated or written off, and its cost stays in your records. See What’s a death pile.

Try the free beta